Talk:Alterac Navy/@comment-644222-20150128090115/@comment-7263041-20150128091034

Okay Everen, let's say you're right that Lordamere is a lake worth defending (keep in mind that again, Alterac has the high ground and can obliterate any naval attack from that lake) when did Alterac build this navy? They couldn't have done it prior to the Second War, because the Lake wasn't owned by them, it was Lordaeron's turf.

Perhaps in the modern day it might be worth defending, but why would the Forsaken bother building ships and sending a navy across the lake, when they can walk around the lake, attack from either of the mountain passes (as they control the southern road and could easily wipe chillwind point off the map from the north if they wanted to) or use batriders and val'kyr to assault Alterac from the air?

There is no logical reason why the Forsaken would ever attempt to attack Alterac from the lake. Therefore there is no logical reason to defend it.