Thread:Vannesira Smith/@comment-1641678-20151213055639/@comment-7263041-20151213092620

Also Vannesira is spot on in regards to you having to prove your point.

Nobble as Vannesira has said, is not a source of lore, he is an interpreter of existing lore, prone to having his own opinions / headcanon (much like you). It's easy to formutate 'what if' opinions and 'this seems likely' headcanon especially when information is missing or vague, but Vannisera actually countered the vagueness of Uther's apparent origin by naming a source where the correct, most up to date lore on the subject could be found.

You're using the Warcraft II manual as a source of lore, where as Vannisera is using a novel published a few years ago. The novel wins out over a manual, every single time.

It is now your responsibility, as someone who originally made the claim, to counter her source with one of your own that can clearly, without any room for misinterpretation, show that Uther is from Northshire. Having looked at the lore myself after Vannisera named her source, I know that you will not be able to find a more up to date source that counters the information presented in Arthas: Rise of the Lich King.