Talk:Marshal/@comment-27186959-20160120122427/@comment-6335668-20160122091704

What you're not grasping is that making them into a list geared around your fanon isn't the right way to do it. There is also, to be blunt, no actual issue with having seperate pages for the links. Your argument of 'cleaner' is ridiculous. We don't have limited space for articles, we can have as many as we want. That is in fact one of the upsides of this website. We do not need to be 'clean' in the way you are advocating for.

Arguably, it will be a stronger wiki if it has pages both for the rank generally and lists of various interpretations. We are stronger for having this page alongside the Grand Alliance Army Ranks and Posts page, and we would be stronger still if we had another page for a different ranking structure. For accessibility, make things link between them, create pages that can be used as a jumping off point - don't try and jam things into a framework based only on your own interpretation.